Random Thoughts
This page is for quick notes and brainstorms. These ideas will eventually be moved into the main protocol or research files.
Metabolic Persistence: BMR, Temperature, and the “Starvation Debt”
These notes explain how chronic illness and fasting affect your metabolism, and how long it really takes for your body to heal.
1. Fasting vs. Starving: The BMR Trap
Proper fasting (like the Scorch Protocol) can actually protect your BMR (metabolic rate) better than simply eating fewer calories for a long time. However, we have to look out for the cumulative debt from months of constant dieting or intermittent fasting (IF).
- The Risk: Just like the famous Minnesota Starvation Experiment showed, eating too little for too long can crash your BMR. This can push your body into a “defensive state” that feels like biological hibernation.
- The Result: If you fast too often without ever giving your body the signal to rebuild, you might end up worse off than if you had just eaten normally.
2. Chronic Illness Makes It Harder
Many chronic illnesses start with a low BMR and a weak immune system. If a virus hits someone who is already metabolically weak, it can cause a Metabolic Crash.
- Functional Hibernation: Your body might act like it’s starving even if you are eating enough food. It simply loses the ability to use that energy correctly.
- Hidden Hypothyroidism: In this state, your blood tests for thyroid hormones (T4/T3) might look “normal,” but you still feel cold, tired, and have a low body temperature. This is called Tissue-Level Resistance.
3. How Long It Takes to Heal
If we look at how people recover from severe starvation, it usually takes 9 months to 2 years for the body to fully reset. This is when your hormones and energy-producing mitochondria finally get back to normal.
- Speeding Up the Process: The Scorch Protocol uses T3 and hGH (Growth Hormone) to try and shorten this 2-year wait.
- Why hGH Works: Studies show that adding Growth Hormone helps people recover much faster. It gives the body a strong “build and repair” signal that overrides the “low-energy” survival mode.
- Why T3 Works: T3 acts like a “metabolic bridge.” It forces your internal furnace to turn back on even when your body is too weak to do it on its own.
The Thermal Threshold: Using Heat to Measure Your Metabolism
Insight: Showering in extreme heat
I was standing in the shower today and realized something profound: I was leaning into extreme hot water, feeling perfectly comfortable. For over 20 years, I haven’t been able to handle that level of heat.
It triggered a memory of a specific, extremely stressful period in my childhood (a time when I gained a significant amount of weight and suddenly started getting many new moles on my body). Since that exact window, I’ve been unable to handle hot tubs, saunas, or even hot showers.
The Correlation: Stress, Torpor, and Thermal Regulation
Looking back, it’s clear: that childhood stress caused my metabolism to take a complete nose dive. My body entered a state of functional hibernation (Torpor). This nosedive resulted in systemic insulin resistance and a drop in Basal Metabolic Rate (BMR) that lasted for decades.
The Gap Explained: Why does a low BMR cause heat intolerance?
When your metabolism is “locked” in torpor, your body’s ability to dissipate heat is as compromised as its ability to generate it. You feel cold easily, but you also feel overwhelmed by external heat because your cellular cooling mechanisms (which require energy!) are offline. Transitioning back to heat tolerance is a major indicator that the “metabolic lock” is breaking.
The Northern European “Freeze”
Think back to the early stages of COVID, when many people complained about “freezing fingertips.” Even when it wasn’t that cold outside, their hands stayed ice-cold. Doctors called this “Raynaud’s Syndrome,” but that’s just a label. It doesn’t explain the real cause.
These symptoms (cold hands, hating heat, weight gain, and skin changes) are all connected. They show that your metabolism is struggling, you have insulin resistance, and your thyroid isn’t working at the cellular level (functional hypothyroidism). This is very common in people of European descent who carry a specific gene called Thr92Ala-DIO2.
Signs of Healing: Feeling Warm
As you go through the Scorch Protocol, watch for changes in how you handle temperature. If you can suddenly enjoy a hot shower, or if your hands stay warm in the wind, it’s a sign that your cells are finally making energy again. You aren’t just “getting used to it”: your body is actually waking up.
The “Energy Gap”: Why COVID-19 Crashed Your Metabolism
The Theory: Why Your Energy Shut Down
There is strong evidence that COVID-19 (and Long Covid) causes a “Panic Shutdown” in cellular energy. This is especially true for people of European descent who have genes (like Thr92Ala-DIO2) that are designed to quickly put the body into hibernation mode during stress.
Controlled Descent vs. Violent Crash
When you fast or go on a keto diet, your body lowers its energy production slowly. It has time to adapt. But COVID-19 was different. It hit the body so hard and so fast that it caused an instant thyroid crash. Your energy production plummeted before your body could even react.
The Computer Analogy: The 100W vs. 50W Gap
Imagine your body is a high-power computer that needs 100 Watts of power to run perfectly. Suddenly, COVID hits your power supply, and you can only produce 50 Watts.
- The Demand: Your brain, heart, and immune system “think” they still have 100 Watts. They are trying to run at full speed.
- The Reality: You only have 50 Watts available.
- The Crash: The computer has to start shutting things down. Your brain slows down (Brain Fog), your immune system stops working, and your hands get cold to save the core.
The bigger this “Energy Gap” is, the more dangerous it becomes. This is why even healthy, athletic people suffered heart attacks or died. Their organs were demanding energy that their crashed mitochondria simply couldn’t provide.
Clots, Sudden Death, and the Keto Shield
Things like blood clots and sudden heart issues are extreme signs of a crashed BMR. When your energy drops too low, your heart loses its electrical stability and your blood gets thicker.
The Irony of Ketosis
Interestingly, people who were already on a keto diet might have had an advantage. Because their metabolism was already “pre-slowed” and they were used to running on lower energy, the jump down to a diseased state wasn’t as big of a shock to their system.
Energy Balance, T3 Therapy, and the “Stone” Paradox
1. How T3 Changes Your “Wattage”
Taking T3 (thyroid hormone) can raise your metabolic rate by 20% to 50%. This is a huge shift. For a large man, T3 can make him need an extra 1,400 calories almost overnight.
- The Gap: If you raise your metabolism but don’t eat enough, your body has to pull that energy from somewhere. In a healthy person, this leads to fat loss. In a sick person, it can lead to a crash.
- Tracking Your Temp: You must track your body temperature often. It tells you if you are actually getting enough calories to support the T3 you are taking.
2. Why T3 Fails Without Enough Food
Trying to use T3 without eating enough is like trying to squeeze blood from a stone. You can’t get energy if the tank is empty.
- Zombie Mode: If your metabolism is extremely low, you might need huge doses of T3 just to feel warm.
- Temporary Gains: T3 therapy often “fails” because the initial energy burst fades into exhaustion. This happens when the body realizes it’s spending more energy than it’s getting from food. You must slowly increase your calories for it to work long-term.
3. The Liver: Your Body’s Battery
Long-term stress and low-carb dieting can weaken your liver’s ability to store and use energy.
- Healing Takes Time: Rebuilding your liver’s energy stores can take a year or more.
- Mixing Fats and Carbs: When your metabolism is slow, eating high fats and high carbs at the same time causes “competition” in your cells. This can increase stress and make it harder to burn glucose.
4. Carbs: The “Fuel” for Your Thyroid
Carbohydrates (carbs) are the most important fuel for your thyroid. They help your body turn T4 into active T3. However, you have to be careful when adding them back into your diet.
- Start Slow: If you haven’t been eating enough, a sudden jump in carbs can cause insulin issues.
- Keep It Simple: In tough cases, simple foods like white rice, fruit, and sugar work best because they are easy to digest. Most people should add carbs back slowly while keeping fats low.
5. The Long Game: Tracking Your Progress
Recovery is a numbers game. You can’t just “guess” if you’re eating enough. Use a food scale and an app (like Cronometer) to track your calories. If you don’t eat enough to match your new T3 energy levels, your body will fight back later and make you gain weight even faster (this is called the Minnesota Starvation Rebound).
- Hormonal Support: You need healthy cholesterol levels to make the hormones your body needs to recover.
- The Tapering Window: When you start lowering your T3 dose, eating a bit extra can help “lock in” your new, higher metabolic rate.
6. The Goal: 100x Better Fasting
Many people think fasting is the only cure. But fasting works 100 times better once your metabolism is already strong. When your BMR is high and your organs are healthy, a dry fast can clear out old cells and boost healing in a way that just doesn’t happen when your body is weak. We rebuild the furnace first so that the fire can do its job.
Genetic Polymorphisms: The Self-Selection Trap
The “Self-Selection” Trap
In fasting communities, you usually only hear from the people who “feel amazing.” This creates a trap. If someone feels terrible while fasting, they usually stop. The people you see doing a 9-day fast are the ones whose genetics are naturally built to handle it.
This is called “survivorship bias.” It makes it look like everyone is a good candidate for fasting, but the “bad candidates” mostly just dropped out without saying anything.
Why Some People Struggle (The European Link)
Many people of European descent have genetics that make them very sensitive to extreme fasting stress. For these people, a long dry fast (or even a few years of carnivore eating) can cause a major metabolic crash.
- The Biggest Mistake: One of the worst things you can do is finish a dry fast and then refeed with only meat and fat (low-carb). Your body needs carbohydrates during the refeed to signal that the stress is over. Without them, your metabolism might not bounce back.
- Insomnia as a Sign: If you can’t sleep after fasting, it could mean two things:
- Pathogens: The stress allowed old viruses or fungi to wake up. This is why the antiviral protocol is so important.
- Genetic Limits: Your body simply isn’t bouncing back 100% after the stress. Each fast might be leaving you slightly weaker than before.
- The “Speed-Run”: If pathogens are the problem, sometimes you have to do a longer (7–9 day) fast to beat them back once and for all. Shorter fasts might not be enough to kill them off.
T3 and the “Genetically Perfect” Guru
The good news is that T3 therapy can often fix this low metabolic state. If your body temperature is usually below 98.6°F, you are likely a good candidate for T3.
The Problem with Gurus: Many health gurus are “genetically perfect.” Their bodies can handle years of low-carb or extreme fasting without any issues. They think that because it worked for them, it will work for everyone. But we all have different genetic foundations, and what works for a “perfect” guru might not work for someone whose metabolism is more sensitive.
The Diminishing Returns Curve: When More Fasting Stops Helping (and the Acidification Magic)
Stem cell regeneration peaks around the Day 3 acidotic crisis and hits a ceiling by Day 5. Past that, autophagy keeps climbing — especially through the second acidotic crisis at Day 7–9, where deeper acidification melts biofilms and reaches what shorter fasts cannot.
The Stem Cell Regeneration Ceiling
There is a point of diminishing returns when it comes to stem cell regeneration during a fast. People say to wait a few weeks before you really start seeing the benefits. Some people feel amazing right off the bat. The truth is nobody really knows the exact point at which you stop getting any more stem cell regeneration. Some people argue Day 3, the first acidotic crisis. Some people argue 5-day dry fasts. Past that, you are potentially going into territory where you are wasting some of it, or even burning out your stem cell pool.
“Burning out” the stem cells is a concept the fasting community talks about. We do not know enough yet to be certain, but it is mechanistically plausible enough to respect as a precaution.
It makes sense not to overfast specifically from a metabolic-state perspective, because if you keep fasts rarer, every fast becomes much more powerful. The rare fast is the powerful fast. This is the opposite of what most fasting communities promote, but the math on the regeneration curve supports it.
The clinical position: once you pass 5 days of dry fasting (or roughly 15 to 20 days of water fasting), you are in territory where you are not going to get much more stem cell regeneration. Those extra days are doing something else.
The Acidification Story: Why Day 7–9 Is Where the Magic Happens
So if extra days past Day 5 are not for stem cell regeneration, what ARE they doing? The answer is in your blood pH.
At the first acidotic crisis around Day 3, blood pH drops from about 7.40 to 7.34. Small numerically, enormous metabolically. That pH drop is the trigger for the standard autophagy and stem cell response. It is the heart of why the 5-day dry fast works for most patients.
But there is a second acidotic crisis that occurs around Day 7 to 9 of dry fasting. At this second crisis, blood pH drops slightly further still, going into acidic territory the body normally never reaches. It is small in the numbers, but huge in what it unlocks.
That deeper acidification is where the real nuclear-option magic happens. The acidic environment literally melts biofilms — the protective shells that shelter Lyme co-infections from immune attack and standard antibiotics. It dramatically accelerates autophagy beyond what the Day 3 crisis triggers. It reaches pathogens and protein aggregates that the standard 5-day fast cannot touch.
This is why a 9-day dry fast can reach what a 5-day dry fast cannot. Not because of the extra days of autophagy on their own, but because of the deeper acidification those extra days produce.
The Nuclear Option: When Extended Dry Fasts Are Justified
Extended dry fasts past the 5-day threshold are NOT for wellness. They are for the cases where you genuinely need a nuclear option:
- Biofilm-protected pathogens – Lyme co-infections (babesia, bartonella) hiding inside biofilms the standard immune response cannot penetrate
- Untrackable Lyme – standard testing fails to confirm the infection but every symptom pattern matches it
- Severe Long Covid – the standard protocol response has not been enough across multiple cycles
- Recurring herpes / cold sore reactivations that resist standard suppressive protocols
- Chronic illness severe enough to be life-threatening – the territory where patients are considering suicide because nothing else has worked
For these patients, the acidification depth and biofilm-melting power of the 7–9 day window IS the protocol. The risk is justified by what is at stake. Filonov in Russia and Della Dewey in Switzerland both run extended dry fasts under medical supervision precisely for this severity tier of patient.
Critical: the refeed protocol becomes proportionally more important as fast length increases. A botched refeed after a 9-day dry fast can erase every gain the fast produced and seed additional viral reactivation. The bar for refeed discipline rises sharply with fast length.
For Everyone Else: Rare and Powerful Beats Long and Frequent
For someone that is literally looking at improvements to their body, metabolism, and constitution, and who is not suffering with chronic illness severe enough to make them consider suicide, dry fasts over 5 days are usually not worth it.
The diminishing returns on stem cell regeneration hit hard past Day 5. The refeed gets more dangerous. The marginal benefit does not justify the marginal risk for non-critical cases. Run a clean 5-day dry fast, refeed correctly, and let the body do its work in the weeks that follow.
This same principle — rare and powerful beats long and frequent — generalizes to T3 cycles and hGH cycles as well. The body responds to hormesis. A rare, sharp intervention produces a stronger response than a long, ground-down intervention. Use the tools sparingly so they keep their power.
The Cavity Signal: Oral Health as an Immune System Indicator
1. The Immune Crash Window
Every serious infection creates an immune vulnerability window. COVID, Long Covid, Lyme, and any chronic illness that ended in ME/CFS share this pattern. The body undergoes an incredible stressor, and the immune system gets degraded for as long as the pathogen is active.
With COVID specifically, your immune system was destroyed for however long the virus was replicating. How deep that damage went depends on three things: how strong your immune system was when you got hit, what medication or support you had access to, and how quickly the virus was cleared.
The parallel to dry fasting is direct. A dry fast creates a brief vulnerability window when you exit. A COVID infection creates the same kind of window, but for much longer, and proportional to how severe the infection was. Some people bounce back in weeks. Others stay in the window for years. That is the ME/CFS endpoint.
2. The Visible Indicator: Cavities
A healthy immune system produces fewer cavities. Forty or fifty years ago, cavities were rare. The change correlates with the introduction of high-sugar diets, which compromised the immune system at the same time as the rise in cancer rates. Both trends share a root cause: a population-level immune system in decline.
Right now, particularly in the last six years, cavities in children have spiked. Run the statistics. Talk to any dentist. The increase is real and accelerating. This is an indicator that children’s immune systems are being damaged at population scale, and the same pattern shows up in chronically ill adults.
I have tons of patients dealing with this. Many of them found out they needed tooth extractions, root canals, and deep work because the body was not putting up any defense against ordinary oral bacteria. This is not primarily a hygiene problem, and it does not have much to do with acid either. It is an immune defense problem expressing itself through the mouth.
3. Fighting on All Fronts: Biome and Immune Together
Oral bacteria are not benign. When the biome is disrupted, the species that win out are the ones that produce the most damage. For some reason, COVID disrupts the biome as well as the immune system, including the oral biome. You end up fighting on both fronts at the same time: less immune capacity, and a more hostile microbial environment.
This is why chronically ill patients often present with 10, 20, or even 30 different things that need addressing or at least kept in mind and observed. The damage is not in one system. It runs across the immune system, the biome, the metabolism, and the connective tissues that depend on all of them. Cavities are just one of the more visible signals.
If you are watching cavities multiply alongside chronic illness, treat them as data. They are pointing at the same root the Scorch Protocol is built to address: immune collapse plus biome disruption. Dental work matters, but it cannot fix the underlying problem on its own.
4. Practical Defense: Tilting the Oral Biome in Your Favor
The deeper repair happens at the immune and metabolic level, but there are things to do right now that shift the oral environment in your favor while the rest of the system is rebuilding:
- Brush more frequently. Twice a day is the minimum. After every meal is better, especially during chronic illness when immune defense is reduced. Mechanical removal of plaque matters more than how aggressive the brushing is.
- Switch to hydroxyapatite toothpaste. Nano-hydroxyapatite (n-HA) is the same calcium-phosphate compound that makes up tooth enamel. It bonds to the tooth surface and remineralizes from the outside in. It is a real non-fluoride alternative with growing research behind it.
- Consider remineralizing chewing gum. Brands like Underbrush combine nano-hydroxyapatite with xylitol and other biome-supportive ingredients. Chewing after meals stimulates saliva (which is itself protective) and delivers remineralizing compounds where they are needed.
None of this replaces the deeper work. Think of it as defense while the immune system is rebuilding. Once the underlying capacity comes back online, the oral biome usually starts trending in the right direction on its own.
Need Personalized Guidance?
What you get: Access to years of highly synthesized data, a personal researcher, coach, and someone who had severe ME/CFS, Long Covid all in one. You will also get personal help with acquiring medication.
Visit DryFastingClub.com